Last Minute Threat of Suit Forces Time Out for Warriors Deal

Neighbors of the proposed basketball stadium on the outskirts of downtown hired attorneys to draft a letter of complaint about the lack of parking, environmental impacts and the speed with which the city has gone about approving the proposal.

City and Golden State Warriors basketball officials said a last minute legal letter given to the Santa Cruz City Council hours before its meeting Tuesday could be a game changer for the proposed $5.6 million stadium planned to open downtown Dec. 23.

The stadium, built in a tent and expected to stay up seven years, would be the first of its kind in the country. The team is the D-league, or minor league franchise for the Warriors now based in North Dakota.

The letter drafted by a San Carlos law firm and passed out by the Beach Hill Neighborhood Association says that the city violated its own codes by not building 1,140 parking spaces with the building that would hold 3,000 people for games or 4,000 for concerts. It would also violate the California Environmental Quality Act by producing greenhouse gases and noise pollution.

And, it says, the project isn't consistent with the city's earlier plan to build 95 apartments in the neighborhood.

"It is important to keep in mind that the Beach Hill Neighbors Association is not necessarily opposed to the stadium arena itself," says the letter, which was giving to the council at 1:30 p.m. Tuesday, before the scheduled 7 p.m. public hearing. "Instead, it is opposed to the Project because it is deficient for the reasons set forth in this letter. Rushing to approve the Project without correcting these deficiencies, could subject the Project to legal challenge resulting in further delay."

Mayor Don Lane stopped the Tuesday night hearing in a packed council chambers, saying that the council would review the legalities in a 1 p.m. meeting Wednesday and probably return for a public hearing at 7 p.m.

The city's planning commission approved the plan unanimously

"This is one of the most selfish acts I've ever witnessed in my life," said Warriors President Jim Weyermann. "It's in total disregard for the economic benefits and well-being for Santa Cruz and it's in total disregard for the overwhelming support that exists for this project."

Weyerman was distressed that the complaint came up at the last minute and thought it was a plan by the neighbors group to get rid of the project despite the earlier public hearing.

City planners and officials had touted the sports and entertainment building as a way to boost business in restaurants and shops, to bring tourists in during the off-season and to help clean up the blighted area between downtown and the Beach Boardwalk. The 33,000-square-foot stadium would be built on a parking lot behind Wheel Works, which is now used for Boardwalk employees, who would be shuttled to the park from another lot downtown.

Because the building – a giant tent like those used for Cirque du Soleil – is a temporary structure, they said they didn't immediately need to do an environmental impact study. City planners also said that there were enough parking places around downtown to accommodate the 3,000 fans who would come to 25 home games.

The San Carlos law firm of Aaronson, Dickerson, Cohn and Lanzone argued that the building is too big, not set back far enough from the road, has no landscaping and is a noise, parking and traffic nuisance. They said the city hadn't done enough study on the impacts to the residential neighborhood around it.

Beach Hill neighborhood member Debbie Jelten, who has lived in the area above the Boardwalk for 23 years, said her concern was for parking. In the summer she often has to walk two blocks to her house because of the beach traffic and parking. She wants the city to restrict the area to permit parking only in the winter as it does already for the summer.

She said traffic in the area was restricted before the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, but was opened up afterwards when much of downtown was destroyed. It was supposed to be a temporary measure, but has remained open, something that she said forced the neighbor's group to take decisive action now.

Residents and planners were surprised at the speed with which the project has moved. It was brought to the city in May and approved by the Planning Commission in three months. Planning Commission Chairman William Schultz called it a model of how the city should operate.

The team has rented an office on Pacific Avenue and printed up Santa Cruz Warriors shirts. The city was planning to loan the team money for construction which would be paid back with interest.

The city has for years been viewed as anti-business and anti-growth. Last year Beach Hill residents and politician Mark Stone helped shoot down a $28 million hotel project at the dilapidated La Bahia apartments on Beach Street which proponents say would have brought in millions of dollars and hundreds of jobs. The hotel was nixed by the Coastal Commission because it was too tall by 14 feet, or 1 1/2 stories over the current limit.

Mayor Lane said the complaints could end the project. Weyerman, the Warriors executive, said that the team wouldn't be able to finish the job by its Dec. 23 opening day if it were held up by legal disputes.

But he said the Warriors have some good lawyers who can answer the complaints.

"Don't count us out," said Weyermann, a former Capitola resident. "We're have great fourth quarter players. They haven't met our legal team yet."

frobert September 12, 2012 at 11:34 PM
To quote as printed in your article ("Don't count us out," said Weyermann, a former Capitola resident. "We're have great fourth quarter players. They haven't met our legal team yet.") it's a battle against the tax paying citizens of Santa Cruz that oppose this project. How did that work out with the La Bahia? The little folk may end up being the "Mouse that Roared" again. I wish the best for them! Coastal Commission Are you awake? People are talking.
Brad Kava September 13, 2012 at 12:01 AM
Gillian thats what they said before they built san jose arena...but learned otherwise over the years. it is a boon for the economy. One city report theorized 100 events but its pretty hard to predict. look how earely the civic is used.
Ron Barr September 13, 2012 at 12:32 AM
Here's an analysis from an environmental attorney who is watching from afar. He has made assumptions based on public records: "The City is trying to approve the project through under a Categorical Exemption (CE) (note - CE's do not require a public comment period like environmental impact reports and mitigated negative declarations), pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act, specifically a Class 32 CE for in-fill development projects. One of the conditions of this CE is that the project can not result in significant impacts to traffic, air quality, noise, and water quality (the group appears to be threatening a lawsuit based on significant impacts to traffic, air quality, and noise). The project appears to comply with the other four conditions of the CE: consistent with General Plan and zoning; occurs in city limits and is less than 5 acres; no habitat of value to endangered species; and can be adequately served by existing utilities and public services. I am not sure what data the applicant (Warriors) and lead agency (City) have to refute the claims that there will be significant impacts to traffic, air quality, and noise. If they have strong, defensible data to refute these claims, there will be little to no delay. If they don't have the data to back up their conclusions, they may need to have studies done to evaluate impacts of the project specific to traffic, air quality, and noise. This could take a few months. I am an environmental consultant by trade."
L. Roxanne Evans September 13, 2012 at 04:22 AM
I heard them state at the hearing tonight that 100 events were planned for the venue. It's been lauded as being available to the community for local sports and other events that would mean more than the Warrior basketball games.
Brad Kava September 13, 2012 at 05:55 AM
They just eliminated rock concerts and amplified concerts, so that will cut down what they can do there in a big way.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »